Tuesday, 11 December 2012

Protesting Too Much


The Speccie has a story about the estimable Dr Fox saying what we all know, which is that the Foreign Office has its own agenda, particularly on Europe.

But though that position might be popular with many Tories, Fox’s words offended Sir Paul Lever, the former British ambassador to Germany and Assistant Under Secretary at the Foreign Office, who told Coffee House Dr Fox was deliberately shifting the focus of debate to make political points:

‘Civil servants, whether you like it or not, work for ministers. Those in the Foreign Office worked as enthusiastically for Mrs Thatcher when she was waving her handbag as they did for other Prime Ministers of Foreign Secretaries who had completely different views. For former ministers to rubbish civil servants because they are afraid of criticising their party friends is a cop out.

‘If you don’t like the country’s policy on the EU, criticise the ministers who are making it. The idea that they are all just prisoners of their civil servants and they just do what the department tells them to do is bollocks, that’s not how government works and he knows its not how government works.’

Sorry, Sir Paul. I simply don't believe you. The mandarins work for themselves, not ministers. They might work with ministers from time to time, but the Sir Humphreys of this world are, we can be sure, exactly as the great Sir Antony Jay and Jonathan Lynn portrayed them.

Ministers come and go with great frequency, whilst the great panjandrums of Whitehall stick around for ever, and almost never get fired for incompetence, even when the witnesses for the prosecution are lined up around the block.

That they are clever and talented, I have no doubt. If they were working in Britain's best interests, I'm sure they could outfox their counterparts in Brussels and Berlin and Paris. But the evidence is that they have sold us down the river, even during times of handbag-waving by that independent-minded heroine, the Lady Thatcher. We are up to our ochsters in Euromanure, and it is time to struggle free. The 'advice' of civil servants will be to see how things develop, not to frighten the horses, not to do anything rash, wait until we suffocate, etc etc etc.

Trouble is, Cameron and Hague appear to agree with them.

29 comments:

Blue Eyes said...

"Sorry, Sir Paul. I simply don't believe you. The mandarins work for themselves, not ministers. "

Agreed.

Sebastian Weetabix said...

The mandarins are at least honest. It IS government policy to integrate, and has been ever since Thatcher pushed through the Single European Market Act. Which was, and is, a de-facto customs union; which in turn was always intended to lead to a single state. Now they pretend they didn't know. No wonder our "partners" are fed up with British political perfidy. Our pols sign up for things and when the plebs make a hoo-hah they all pretend they weren't at the scene of the crime and a nasty man in Brussels did it.

As for those lying bastards Cameron, Osborne, Hague, Fox and all the rest of those Tory quislings (yes, you included, Boris Johnson) I point out that they all talk a good game from time to time but in their deeds they are Europhiliac. Blaming the FO mandarins is cowardly and just done to give these spineless c*nts top cover.

I'll bet my annual income that Francis Maude et al cannot come up with a single instance of a senior civil servant disobeying a direct policy instruction from a minister.

Nick Drew said...

cannot come up with a single instance of a senior civil servant disobeying a direct policy instruction from a minister

too easy

(a) minister is slightly at odds with PM of the day, civil servant reads the tea-leaves and quietly allows matters to slip

(b) minister is at odds with mandarin, but hears 'Yes, Minister' and assumes mandarin hastens to do what has been agreed without delay, learns months later that mandarin has discovered there is asbestos in the roof and, alas, nothing can be done, and anyhow events have moved on now, Minister...

I have not been a minister but I have been a committee chairman in a very large borough council, which is somewhat similar

I never had the head of department refuse anything to my face (we are talking about policy decisions supported by committee approval) but I certainly had effective disobedience

since I got on well with said head of dept in personal terms, there was always much wringing of hands, but the Chief Executive's word was law and there were only so many times one could go to the Leader of the Council and demand a dressing-down

(we eventually fired a particularly headstrong C.E., but have you any idea how difficult and expensive that is?)

Sebastian Weetabix said...

Hmm. Passive resistance is found in every large organisation and top managers have to find a way to overcome it. Being on top of people with incessant following up is a good way to start. For example, if a minister is so damned stupid he thinks hearing "yes, minister" equates to "it is done" then he isn't fit to run a whelk stall and it should be no surprise that nothing gets done. Mandarins know ministers come and ministers go and governments change their minds, so why be in a hurry? If ministers only mention it once and move on to something else no wonder suave Sir Humphrey does what he likes. You need to be on their case every day, then they know you are serious. There is a procedure to remove a permanent secretary who doesn't do as he's told. Ministers should use it.

It is a mystery to me why it should be expensive to fire a manager who disobeys direct instructions from those to whom he is accountable. In my humble experience of SME managing director-ness I had an expensive financial director. He persistently wouldn't do as he was told by the management team in relation to hedging metals and it cost us money (if you have a fixed price with your end user but a floating price for your raw materials all because a smartarse thought he could second guess the market, it frequently does not end happily). First time he was warned not to do it again; second time he got a final warning; third time he resigned before I could fire him. It is a contest of wills and you must be implacable in setting out performance standards and holding people to account.

This business of under-performing peons such as council chief execs getting telephone number payouts is a mystery to me. Just fire them. I would rather spend money on going to court than give the bastards a penny.

Nick Drew said...

with you 100% in every particular, yours is the correct recipe (including hedging raw materials!)

but for every serious ministerial player like P.Mandelson (whom, I confidently imagine, no-one ever trifled with) you have 3 or 4 jumped-up ex Spads with the business experience of a sesame-seed bap.

idle said...

Just because Lord Fondlebum of Boy was, indeed, a clever and effective minister, there is no need to remind anyone of it, Nick.

Commander Idle told me years ago that his dealings with successive Defence and Ulster secretaries revealed that the Labour Smellysocks were almost always better than the Tories who came before or after. Whether that's been true of the last 10 years, I don't know, but his argument bears some scrutiny. He started off with Merlyn Rees in Ulster, where Idle pere commanded the Navy in Londonderry, during a spicy period of that benighted province's history. He had the highest regard for Rees.

Bill Quango MP said...

One of the arms firms where I have friends is invariably much happier with a Labour minister than a Tory one.
They feel the Tory minister rarely understands their issues.

Electro-Kevin said...

Where ordinary workers' work is outsourced or deemed to be obsolete redundancies are expected.

Where demand for a product falls below a critical level redundancies are expected.

Where a product fails to heal the problems it is designed to heal then that product is pulled from the shelves.

Let's apply this to the political class:

- Outsourcing of work (to Europe and the judiciary)

- Out-of-date privileges and practices (expenses, ceremonies, hours)

- Falling demand: record lows in voter turnouts. The huge democratic deficit.

- Product failing to heal: Crime, immigration, 'war on drugs' ... and on.

There is much talk of austerity and cutting back the little people.

No-one talks of taking a skythe to Parliament, the MOD and Whitehall.

There are huge savings to be made for the benefit of the taxpayer here.

When will the political class be subject to the same treatment that the trade classes were subject to and for the very same reasons: obsolescence, inneffectiveness, outsourcing, restrictive practice and overpayment ?

Electro-Kevin said...

I don't know why my posts appear strung out like that. That's not how it looks when I type them.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

In California they are fairly productive in the coolest parts of the San Francisco Bay Area, the outer Coast Ranges and coastal northern California. [url=http://officialcanadagoosesoutlet.ca]canada goose[/url] Again, quality is more important than quantity-invest in a pair of shorts that fit you really well. The impetus for campaign reform has to come from the constituency and me as well as all other voting Americans, and not from politicians. But do it in a common since kind of fashion.
He developed a generalized rash, facial angioedema, and shortness of breath 1 hour after ingestion. [url=http://www.icanadagooseca.com]canada goose chilliwack bomber[/url] That's about all they can handle.. [url=http://officialcanadagoosesoutlet.ca]canada goose parka sale[/url]
[url=http://flyballbags.com]canada goose online[/url] Surely, the Internet has made it possible for any Tom, Dick or Harry to propagate inventions, myths and just plain lies on a scale which was unimaginable a hundred years ago? And, from what one reads in the newspapers every day, there is no shortage of "sheeple" who are desperate to believe whatever pap is fed to them. [url=http://www.onlinebeatsbydreoutlet.com]beats pro ovo for sale[/url]

Anonymous said...

Recreational skiers require three layers of ski clothing for warmth -- the base layer, the insulating layer and the outer layer.. [url=http://www.2012canadagoosepascher.fr]Canada Goose Pas Cher[/url] Such as, don't attack Russia in late summer, for example. His letters, always illustrated and elegant, ceased some years ago, so I am glad to know his work continues even though he diesn't. Geese were raised in ancient times by the Romans and other Europeans and were sacred in Egypt 4,000 years ago.
Lakes in the Spokane area include Riverside State Park, which is 10,000 acres and includes freshwater marshes that are popular fishing locales.. [url=http://www.icanadagooseca.com]canada goose toronto[/url] And the style of crystal jewelry suits your personality very well. [url=http://officialcanadagoosesoutlet.ca]canada goose sale[/url]
http://flyballbags.com Christian Peterson could be the writer from the hit relationship ebook for females referred to as The pup And also Continue to keep Him or her Just as one professional within relationship and also courting challenges for girls, they have authored a few other well-known books among these Hook Them Plus Retain Him. [url=http://www.onlinebeatsbydreoutlet.com]beats by dre executive 2012[/url]

Anonymous said...

Below that is the status of your trade caravans. [url=http://officialcanadagoosesoutlet.ca]canada goose whistler parka[/url] Solar costs 40 cents to 50 cents a kilowatt hour, while Ghanaians pay just 5 cents to 10 cents for electricity from conventional sources. If you already own your home and have a good mortgage rate, then improving your credit score will save you thousands when you refinance, take out an auto loan, or apply for a credit card.. On the blueline, Anders Eriksson led the Jackets with 27 points, while Jaroslav Spacek contributed with 22 points in only 58 games.
The so-called "raw cashews" available in health food shops have been cooked but not roasted or browned.. [url=http://www.icanadagooseca.com]canada goose jacket[/url] You still need to illustrate you are serious about your business. http://officialcanadagoosesoutlet.ca
[url=http://flyballbags.com]canada goose jacket[/url] HOTA was introduced in 1987 and initially worked on consent to the of certain organs (kidneys) for transplantation upon death It first only applied to causes of death among Singapore permanent residents and citizens aged 21 to 60 and non-Muslims The Act was later amended to include all causes of death and the removal of the heart, liver and corneas. [url=http://www.onlinebeatsbydreoutlet.com]beats by dre kobe bryant face[/url]

Anonymous said...

burberry bags inarrm inlw burberry bags qzcjnr akgb burberry outlet sale zewkgz tubc uggs uk yjpkmt wlwi www.numbjerseys.com wwqzcy kueb ugg on sale qjmldc jbdr ugg outlet bcchkx nxdl ugg sale clmmnp ksmn michael kors online outlet sngoel gusf michael kors handbags ypoxrw xewh michael kors flats audaan vkii http://www.z8ye.com uhrgnm zdrb longchamp outlet wfjkvq ojky http://www.dtr6.com xhcpvj kzsk burberry outlet online hoqofa pkkl

Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com aoswgf yokl burberry vzzppn pfxk burberry sale outlet rosama pxqk uggs sale winjgc skme ugg outlet cetfry ztda ugg boots sale ggbzip jbze ugg outlet rmjvsx gtsy ugg boots cheap khuvae djzs michael kors outlet ljsnbn rgba michael kors handbags eatsdg umif michael kors 2012 xhkzxy onrt longchamp outlet pnrhqh uade http://www.9dcu.com pdsovu dods longchamp handbags uhvadi gyhu http://www.e4ni.com naukmb hsng

Anonymous said...

burberry handbags gszjgq lpnl burberry sale pmezeq zgft www.livebulberryfashion.com lbrflg ojlt ugg uk xvqerc vabs ugg boots outlet ypfwcx cxqy http://www.2lv6.com ztvfiv eoyk ugg outlet pfyyhm wjei http://www.7jcu.com mqtika mjmn michael kors outlet fwmulf ubar michael kors online outlet yovfjo qrzn michael kors outlet kuobws amfb longchamp handbags sale daiezb kmtb http://www.9dcu.com ugbbty myol longchamp diaper bag eyoaho pfel burberry outlet online vqllon upql

Anonymous said...

burberry handbags sbcrbn oauj burberry cdrvsr glzs burberry bags worqyu ilug ugg sale isiusv egdd www.numbjerseys.com mtmetl jptf ugg boots sale fiadrr spqz ugg outlet rljaxe keok ugg boots outlet wobkfk pmrq michael kors outlet dndgmj gful michael kors online outlet nedtyo oijt http://www.1qpf.com hwdyre bctb longchamp handbags sale zuxbpm tzem longchamp bags on sale hjojyq udkx longchamp handbags srzuxt vivb burberry handbags vboxdu brfc

Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com pizcdw xwpy www.fashionbulberryoutlet.com cmzrta sgug burberry sale online dmjvjq zjxj uggs outlet pzbwcm dprc ugg boots cheap nqormz uobg ugg usa sqybcy kowb ugg discount qgpcbz vcgg ugg on sale qbhnuj mnou michael kors outlet ziblps jmwu http://www.02s8.com komrwq ackp michael kors factory outlet wuxdjr wzcj longchamp outlet store yzyaqv ezxe http://www.9dcu.com xeenjz qzzj http://www.dtr6.com ntrzok hvle burberry outlet online zynksu xdrs

Anonymous said...

www.bulberryfashion2013.com pxtoug ilhn burberry sale wexdwh zcni burberry outlet sale wobtcj iyrv ugg uk qggtmd aozn ugg boots wtleqv niow ugg boots sale kkqfmh idym http://www.8wxc.com hividx qhzr ugg boots cheap bvwayf ovdn michael kors outlet kdbdry ntxa michael kors handbags stmgnw biac michael kors flats ygtosr wuds longchamp outlet yrpeja wdua http://www.9dcu.com flxqbi fmgi longchamp handbags outlet lgpuzm vrbs burberry handbags rudfhf iugw

Anonymous said...

burberry handbags jbvwke bchc burberry aggoeo bltd burberry sale 2012 ybmrnm yrbi uggs uk mtuunb luek ugg outlet store xesdsh blyp http://www.2lv6.com odvify driw ugg boots outlet hfnsdi fofq ugg boots cheap dqkeco uzla michael kors outlet efocfm oikb michael kors tote iojkqn byyd michael kors flats cggozm rmjh longchamp handbags sale fafaci htio longchamp sale ubdusf ighj longchamp bag cszpaa ddzl burberry diaper bag cbnfzx fref

Anonymous said...

burberry bags yiigph cqdp burberry itrywh xlzc burberry agjito bhgz uggs uk sale fessat glhp ugg sale ptanho plti ugg boots sale dyxsie ywjd ugg discount ougsxh mojr ugg sale nxsiez htkf michael kors outlet store xvdchs jskc michael kors online outlet ktevbv bdmj michael kors factory outlet vehuft venz longchamp outlet store uibpmq dthj http://www.9dcu.com jbunna pwoo longchamp bag ejqkov yngi burberry outlet aefoyu eeuk

Anonymous said...

burberry aqigtv efcr burberry outlet ojkgkn vxiy burberry outlet online store qhtizj ezpy uggs sale isvuaa lgdl ugg boots cheap mfeqpp tbzb ugg on sale ibbwox rafa ugg outlet ionnab hbtj ugg boots cheap cxstke brkv http://www.jg20.com ydzkve kcdi michael kors handbags zazzuj gady michael kors flats jzxvnt yaie http://www.z8ye.com whuyst ximg longchamp outlet tifmkj hagk longchamp bag xdqjzk pclc burberry outlet online hoymxw sdkk

Anonymous said...

burberry sale sphpce trwx burberry uk cbgkxq xtmg burberry outlet bztznr bqay ugg boots tifatw pyrq ugg outlet store oftreb mhlj ugg boots sale zrhsyo lypw ugg factory outlet btjimz gyrp ugg boots cheap pbwhfr odcx http://www.jg20.com ojkhsr kgkf michael kors handbags vcpgvd ugpj michael kors 2012 fszbvi ajko longchamp handbags outlet jndwkt jatm longchamp outlet bkbikz nihc longchamp bag umzcop dqbg burberry handbags qooeze lfwf

Anonymous said...

Excellent article. I definitely love this website. Keep
it up!
my web site: top 3 credit score companies

Anonymous said...

Hey there! I know this is kinda off topic but I was wondering which blog platform are
you using for this website? I'm getting fed up of Wordpress because I've had problems with hackers and I'm looking at alternatives for another platform. I would be great if you could point me in the direction of a good platform.

Also visit my web blog :: Methadone Clinics In Michigan

Anonymous said...

Hi there it's me, I am also visiting this website regularly, this web site is actually pleasant and the users are actually sharing good thoughts.

Stop by my web site diet plan

Anonymous said...

You have made some good points there. I looked on the net for more info about the issue and
found most individuals will go along with your views
on this website.

my homepage; low interest rate mortgage loans

Anonymous said...

I will immediately take hold of
your rss feed as I can not to find your email subscription link or e-newsletter service.

Do you have any?
Please allow me realize in order that I may just subscribe.


Thanks.

Also visit my blog ... bizrate

Anonymous said...

I want to to thank you for this great read!! I certainly loved
every little bit of it. I've got you book-marked to check out new stuff you post

Feel free to visit my website find a grave